My weblog ELECTRON BLUE, which concentrated on science and mathematics, ran from 2004-2008. It is no longer being updated. My current blog, which is more art-related, is here.

Thu, 30 Jun, 2005

Right answer, but still perplexed

I've been doing physics problems from Barron's chapter 4, and usually I get them correct. The trouble is, I don't know why I get them correct. All I'm doing is plugging the numbers into the formulas which I have attempted to memorize. It's the opposite of those frustrating mathematical moments I described about a year ago (for instance, when I was studying Logarithms) where I could not get any of the problems right even though I understood what was required to solve them.

This part of classical mechanics seems to be a shifting kaleidoscope of different quantities such as impulse, momentum, angular momentum, spatial extension, velocity, acceleration, mass, weight, gravity, time and force, all of which seem to be able to be multiplied by each other despite their very different qualities. Kilograms/meters/seconds, velocity2/radius length, and force * time. I am finding it hard to keep track of all of them. The problems are solved by combining and recombining them in the formulas. I am remotely aware that all of these things profoundly and precisely describe the "rea,l" at least the macroscopic, world, but I feel far away from experiencing them and understanding how they really do combine. Newton's apple has not dropped from the tree, it is still floating up there as if gravity had no pull on it, as if there were no Newtons of force acting upon it. But what's the difference between the force of gravity and the acceleration of gravity? Will I ever eat the apple?

What's the point of getting the problems right if I don't understand the material? And then should I dare to ask questions? If momentum is mass x velocity, then do photons, which have no mass but do have velocity, have momentum? Yeah, I shouldn't ask about photons, it seems like it will be years before I advance enough in physics to deal with them rather than with cannonballs, wheels, and orbiting Keplerian planets.

I know that these formulaic entities are part of my real life; my Electron Car's path along the road is a complex combination of forces and vectors and acceleration and friction and torque and momentum. I have no laboratory or workshop where things can be isolated and demonstrated, though I suppose I could find space somewhere if I tried. But the world is so full of phenomena that I hardly know where to start.

Posted at 1:08 am | link

Why the Title?
About the Author
What this blog is about: the first post
Pyracantha Main Page

RSS Version


November 2014 (4)
October 2014 (16)
September 2008 (5)
August 2008 (5)
July 2008 (7)
June 2008 (4)
May 2008 (6)
April 2008 (5)
March 2008 (8)
February 2008 (9)
January 2008 (8)
December 2007 (9)
November 2007 (9)
October 2007 (1)
September 2007 (7)
August 2007 (6)
July 2007 (10)
June 2007 (7)
May 2007 (10)
April 2007 (7)
March 2007 (11)
February 2007 (10)
January 2007 (6)
December 2006 (9)
November 2006 (9)
October 2006 (8)
September 2006 (8)
August 2006 (10)
July 2006 (9)
June 2006 (10)
May 2006 (10)
April 2006 (8)
March 2006 (12)
February 2006 (10)
January 2006 (11)
December 2005 (11)
November 2005 (9)
October 2005 (10)
September 2005 (10)
August 2005 (12)
July 2005 (9)
June 2005 (10)
May 2005 (8)
April 2005 (7)
March 2005 (8)
February 2005 (9)
January 2005 (7)
December 2004 (7)
November 2004 (7)
October 2004 (8)
September 2004 (5)
August 2004 (9)
July 2004 (9)
June 2004 (8)
May 2004 (6)
April 2004 (13)
March 2004 (12)
February 2004 (13)


Cosmic Variance
Life as a Physicist
Cocktail Party Physics
Bad Astronomy
Jennifer Saylor
Thus Spake Zuska

Listed on Blogwise